Are Premier League standings misleading?

Is the Premier League table telling the full story? We explore how standings can mislead and what the underlying data really says about team performance.

The league table is football’s ultimate authority. After every matchday, it tells us who’s flying, who’s struggling, and who’s in trouble. But over the course of a season, the Premier League table doesn’t always tell the full story.

Results matter, but they don’t happen in a vacuum. Finishing streaks, defensive errors, refereeing decisions, and simple luck all influence where teams sit. Looking beyond the table helps explain why some teams feel better or worse than their position suggests.

Why league tables don’t always reflect performance

A team that wins games climbs the table, regardless of how those wins arrive. That’s the point of the competition, but wins alone don’t tell the full story. 

A side might win several matches thanks to clinical finishing or top-tier goalkeeping, even while being outplayed. Another might dominate games and create loads of chances, but still drop points due to missed opportunities or bad breaks.

Over short runs, these differences can distort the bigger picture. The table reflects results accurately, but it doesn’t always reflect how well teams are actually playing.

The role of luck in football results

Luck plays a bigger role in football than many fans like to admit. Goals are relatively rare events overall, which means small moments and a lucky break can swing matches in an instant. 

Deflections, rebounds, penalties, and refereeing calls all affect outcomes. And so do factors like opposition injuries or the timing of fixtures. Over time, luck tends to balance out, but across a few matches or part of a season, it can push teams above or below their underlying level.

This is why some teams that got “lucky” earlier on in a season often experience a drop-off or a surge. The performances haven’t changed much, but the results finally catch up.

Are Premier League standings misleading?

Sometimes, yes. Especially over short periods.

The table tells you what happened. Performance metrics help explain why. When the two align, the picture is clear. When they don’t, that gap is often where luck comes into play. 

Understanding both sides gives a clearer view of how the Premier League really works, beyond just the numbers in the standings.

What expected metrics add to the picture

Expected goals, or xG, helps cut through some of that noise. xG measures the quality of chances created and conceded, rather than whether shots result in goals.

A team consistently creating high xG while conceding little is usually performing well, even if results lag behind. On the flip side, teams scoring far more goals than their xG suggests may be riding a finishing streak that’s unlikely to last.

Expected points, or xPTS, goes a step further. It estimates how many points a team should have earned based on the chances in their matches. Comparing xPTS to actual points helps highlight teams overperforming or underperforming relative to their play.

Alternative tables and “true” performance

When you sort teams by xG difference or xPTS instead of points, the table often looks very different. Some clubs drop several places, while others climb.

These alternative tables don’t replace the real standings, but provide extra details and context. They help explain why certain teams look vulnerable despite strong results, or why others feel unlucky. 

Shot quality, chance creation, and overall match control all contribute to this bigger picture. Over a full season, teams that rank well in these areas usually move closer to where the underlying data suggests they belong.

The Lucky Table: Follow football’s lucky finishers

The Premier League table shows results. The Lucky Table shows where those results might be running ahead of performances.

By comparing goals scored to expected goals, the Lucky Table highlights teams and players who are outperforming the chances they create, as well as those falling short despite strong underlying play. It adds context to league position and helps explain why some teams feel more fragile or more unlucky than the league table suggests.

If you want more than just the standings, Match Bingo helps you read between the lines.

Download now!